Close Menu
Invest Intellect
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Invest Intellect
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • Home
    • Commodities
    • Cryptocurrency
    • Fintech
    • Investments
    • Precious Metal
    • Property
    • Stock Market
    Invest Intellect
    Home»Investments»Judge strikes down Missouri anti-ESG investment rules, SIFMA wins lawsuit
    Investments

    Judge strikes down Missouri anti-ESG investment rules, SIFMA wins lawsuit

    August 15, 20243 Mins Read


    A federal judge Wednesday struck down a pair of year-old Missouri investment rules that regulated “non-financial” investment advice from broker-dealers and investment advisors.

    Judge Stephen Bough of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri issued the order the day after hearing oral arguments from both parties, which had submitted dueling summary judgment motions. He ordered a statewide permanent injunction prohibiting the implementation, application, or enforcement of the rules.

    Missouri Secretary of State John R. Ashcroft enacted the regulation after lawmakers failed to pass a bill with the same goals. SIFMA’s complaint named Ashcroft and Missouri’s Securities Commissioner Douglas Jacoby as defendants.

    A spokesperson for Ashcroft’s office said Bough’s ruling was “not just legally deficient but also morally wrong.”

    The two rules require broker-dealers and investment advisors to disclose and obtain written consent from customers to buy or sell an investment product based on environmental, social or other non-financial objectives.

    "This decision marks a major victory not only for our national securities market system, but also for our nation," said SIFMA President and CEO Kenneth E. Bentsen, Jr., about a court ruling that struck down a pair of Missouri investment rules.
    “This decision marks a major victory not only for our national securities market system, but also for our nation,” said SIFMA President and CEO Kenneth E. Bentsen, Jr., about a court ruling that struck down a pair of Missouri investment rules.

    SIFMA

    The annual disclosure requirement includes language that says incorporating ESG considerations “will result” in investments and advice “that are not solely focused on maximizing a financial return for the client.” Client consent in the form of a signature is required every three years.

    SIFMA, which sued the state last August, argued that the rules are preempted by two federal laws, the National Securities Markets Improvement Act, and the Employment Retirement Income Security Act. The association also claimed the rules violate the First Amendment by requiring firms to adopt and express the state’s position on the “nonfinancial” nature of ESG investing, and are unconstitutionally vague.

    Bough ruled in SIFMA’s favor on all four counts. On the NSMIA question, the judge wrote the rules are preempted because each one “impermissibly imposes new and different state regulatory obligations that are not required by federal law.” On the ERISA count, Bough cites SIFMA in saying the rules “undermine ERISA’s exclusive enforcement scheme and are therefore preempted.”

    The court also agreed with SIFMA that the rules violate the First and Fourteenth Amendment as unconstitutionally vague — failing to adequately define “nonfinancial objectives” — and compelling language that is, among other things, controversial. Bough cites a ruling Missouri Times column by Ashcroft titled “Opinion: It’s Time to Rein In ESG,” and notes that these “statements discussing political priorities are not uncontroversial.”

    In an emailed statement, Ashcroft’s office said Bough’s ruling was “puts Missouri investors at risk,” and that the “secretary of state’s office will neither abandon its statutory duty to regulate securities nor allow Missouri investors to be preyed upon by investment individuals that are afraid to be upfront and honest about their investment advice.”

    SIFMA president and CEO Kenneth E. Bentsen, Jr. said the “decision marks a major victory not only for our national securities market system, but also for our nation.”

    “Under today’s federal securities laws, financial professionals are already required to provide investment advice and recommendations that are in their customers’ best interest,” Benstsen said. “That means they cannot put their interests ahead of their customers’ interests when recommending securities. The Missouri rules were thus unnecessary and created confusion.”



    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

    Related Posts

    RBI urges banks, corporates to drive investments amid tariff, geopolitical uncertainties | Business News

    Investments

    DoDEA Day Strengthens Bonds Between Educators and Military Community at Ramstein Air Base | Article

    Investments

    The smarter property bet lenders can’t ignore

    Investments

    More than 50 percent of Hongkongers plan to work past retirement age

    Investments

    India bonds rise as Powell’s dovish remarks partly offset fiscal concerns

    Investments

    Prudently managing post-retirement portfolio need of the hour

    Investments
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Picks
    Investments

    Investments into Isas up 11% in Q1

    Investments

    Garber Will Not Review Harvard’s Investments for Ties to Human Rights Violations | News

    Cryptocurrency

    New Cryptocurrency Releases, Listings, & Presales – ZKCrypt, AI Agent Factory, Memeseco

    Editors Picks

    Onyx Gold lève 2,03 millions de dollars dans le cadre de la deuxième tranche d’un placement privé sans courtier

    June 6, 2025

    Le forage au diamant commence au projet Fiesta Copper, Namibie Faits saillants

    April 9, 2025

    Forest food production key in agricultural output

    March 21, 2025

    Budget 2024: How removing indexation benefits for capital gains tax on property may impact the Mumbai real estate market

    August 5, 2024
    What's Hot

    Gold declines Rs 200 to Rs 89,100 per 10 g, silver trades flat – ThePrint – PTIFeed

    March 6, 2025

    McKinsey: energy sector ‘reality gap’ widening between decarbonisation commitments and realisation

    August 29, 2024

    Faches-Thumesnil : Le chanteur du groupe Iron Maiden participe à une compétition d’escrime

    January 19, 2025
    Our Picks

    Top ASX Dividend Stocks To Watch In October 2024

    October 15, 2024

    State Street Global Advisors buys stake in Australian fintech Raiz

    August 27, 2024

    Numérique et irrationalité : retour sur l’USI d’Octo Technology

    June 12, 2025
    Weekly Top

    RBI urges banks, corporates to drive investments amid tariff, geopolitical uncertainties | Business News

    August 25, 2025

    Buy Wheaton Precious Metals Stock At $93?

    August 25, 2025

    Permits were expedited for this California clean energy project. Were residents sidelined?

    August 25, 2025
    Editor's Pick

    Podcast BFM Business – BFM Bourse avec Guillaume Sommerer.

    July 4, 2025

    ‘Crypto Czar’, Silicon Valley investors to meet Donald Trump. Big Cryptocurrency order coming soon?

    March 6, 2025

    Chartwell annonce la distribution d’avril 2025 et fait le point sur le taux d’occupation

    April 15, 2025
    © 2025 Invest Intellect
    • Contact us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.