Close Menu
Invest Intellect
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Invest Intellect
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • Home
    • Commodities
    • Cryptocurrency
    • Fintech
    • Investments
    • Precious Metal
    • Property
    • Stock Market
    Invest Intellect
    Home»Property»Property tax relief bill logjam breaks loose
    Property

    Property tax relief bill logjam breaks loose

    April 16, 20257 Mins Read


    Weeks of apparent legislative gridlock on measures aiming to offer Montana homeowners relief for rising residential property taxes broke loose Wednesday as lawmakers on the Senate Taxation Committees voted forward heavily amended versions of two major taxbills, one of them the second-home tax backed by Republican Gov. Greg Gianforte.

    The Gianforte proposal, House Bill 231, and an alternative, House Bill 155, will now advance to debate on the Senate floor. Both bills still face several hurdles before they can head to the governor’s desk, including floor votes, the Senate Finance and Claims Committee and potential conference committee meetings to reconcile Senate-side amendments with language that passed the House in February. Assuming one or both bills survive the remainder of that journey, further amendments are likely to come along the way.

    The Senate Taxation Committee also voted down a third prominent tax relief push Wednesday, House Bill 528. Sponsored by Rep. Ed Byrne, R-Bigfork, that bill would have essentially implemented a tax rate rebalancing proposal championed by Democratic candidate for governor Ryan Busse as he campaigned against Gianforte last year. It was opposed by a wide variety of business interests who argued it would shift too much tax burden from residences to farms and business properties.

    The Gianforte-backed proposal, developed by House Appropriations Chair Llew Jones, R-Conrad, would scale down taxes on primary residences and long-term rental properties, raising them on second homes and Airbnb-style short-term rentals in an effort to limit how much tax burden is shifted onto business properties. Like most of the other tax proposals considered by the Legislature this year, it aims to provide homeowner tax relief without reducing the local tax revenues that fund services including schools, law enforcement and parks departments.

    In order to impose higher taxes on second homes, the state Department of Revenue would need to begin tracking which of Montana’s residential properties are and aren’t being used as primary residences, a potentially tricky administrative task that has been a source of worry for the bill’s opponents. While the bill directs the department to use the list of owner-occupied homes that received one-off property tax rebates over the past two years as a starting point, the department would need to run a new application process to catch long-term rental properties and the tens of thousands of homeowners who qualified for those rebates but didn’t successfully apply.

    Among the changes lawmakers made to the Gianforte-Jones relief bill Wednesday was an amendment that acknowledges it’s now too late for the department to differentiate between primary and secondary homes for the property tax bills that will be mailed this fall. Instead, the version of the bill that passed the tax committee provides for a third round of rebates, up to $400 a homeowner, and scales down residential taxes regardless of occupancy status on an interim basis. Both those provisions could be amended as lawmakers consider other bills that could provide one-time or ongoing rebates.

    The tax committee also amended the Gianforte-Jones bill to specify that land in fee ownership within the bounds of American Indian reservations is automatically eligible for the lower tax rates for primary residence — an effort to address concerns that Native homeowners could be saddled with higher tax rates intended for second homes if they end up disenfranchised by the application process.

    Additionally, lawmakers took a stab at addressing concerns about how the rate rebalancing employed by the Gianforte-Jones bill would collide with a provision of the Billings city charter.

    Like other proposals that aim to rebalance the property tax system by dialing back residential tax rates to offset the rapid home value growth, the Gianforte-Jones bill would shrink the total taxable value of tax bases across the state. In most jurisdictions, the millage rates used to calculate property taxes would adjust automatically so cities, counties, towns and cities receive the same amount of tax revenue. However, officials from both Billings, the state’s most populous city, and Sunburst, a population-351 town in north-central Montana, have told lawmakers that their municipal charters contain provisions that would keep that adjustment from happening, potentially forcing them to cut their budgets.

    Language added to the Gianforte-Jones bill Wednesday aim to address that concern by specifying that the Legislature intends to have its tax relief legislations preempt those charters. It also specifies that the state will reimburse cities for lost revenues in the coming years if that legislative intent fails to hold up in a court case.

    The amended Gianforte-Jones passed the Senate Taxation Committee on a bipartisan 6-2 vote, though several lawmakers described their support as “reluctant.”

    “I’ve committed to Rep. Jones to get this bill out of here,” said Senate Taxation Chair Greg Hertz, R-Polson. “I don’t like it — it’s more or less a Frankenstein bill now, but I hope we get it out of here so we can have the discussion on the [Senate] floor.”

    The other bill advanced by the tax committee Wednesday, SB 155, was initially pitched by Democrats as an alternative to the Gianforte-Jones bill. As introduced by Rep. Mark Thane, D-Missoula, it would have used a tiered rate bracket structure to lower taxes for middle- and low-value properties while offsetting some of those savings with increases on high-value homes regardless of their occupancy status. Supporters have argued that the bill would provide a path to middle-class tax relief without the administrative burden of tracking which homes are being used as primary residences.

    Republicans on the tax committee, however, amended SB 155 to rework its central language Wednesday before passing it forward over opposition from the committee’s Democrats. As the bill is now structured, it contains comparatively modest rate rebalancing for residential, commercial and agricultural properties, as well as a homestead exemption making the first $50,000 of value for primary residences tax free.

    RELATED


    Property taxes, explained — with pictures

    Property taxes, explained — with pictures

    Property values have risen dramatically in Montana, but that doesn’t necessarily mean you (or your landlord) will pay higher property taxes. If you want to know why, read our property tax explainer — with pictures.


    Those changes to the tax code, Hertz said, would mitigate the 11% increase in residential taxes projected as a result of this year’s reappraisal cycle. It wouldn’t, however, adjust rates to account for the historic increase to residential tax values that drove homeowner taxes up by 21% on median in the 2023 cycle.

    Hertz said the reworked version of the bill would dovetail with a proposal like Senate Bill 90, which would redirect some revenue from the state’s lodging tax toward annual property tax rebates.

    Sen. Dave Fern, D-Whitefish, responded that he was skeptical that a rebate-forward proposal would pass muster with the governor.

    RELATED


    Gianforte’s second-home tax faces legislative headwinds

    Gianforte’s second-home tax faces legislative headwinds

    An email sent to some of the state’s most prominent business lobbyists by the lawmaker advancing Gov. Greg Gianforte’s signature property tax relief bill indicates that the bill may be in political jeopardy as it competes with another proposal moving through the Montana Legislature. The sponsor carrying the governor’s bill, Rep. Llew Jones, R-Conrad, expressed optimism he could salvage his legislation.


    “I think folks don’t want rebates,” Fern said. “I’m not sure that we can get it through the second floor with the tension we have about who possesses what bucket and how it can be used.”

    The lodging tax dollars that would be tapped by SB 90 currently provide a minor revenue stream into the state General Fund, which is primarily filled with state income taxes. Gianforte, whose office is on the second floor of the Capitol, has repeatedly said he doesn’t want to pay for property tax relief with income tax dollars.

    SB 90 has stalled in the House Taxation Committee but has been partially incorporated into a sprawling trust bill, House Bill 924, that is currently under consideration by the Senate Finance and Claims Committee. Also sponsored by Jones, the Legislature’s longtime budget guru, HB 924 would use hundreds of millions from the state’s current budget surplus and a portion of future income tax collections to set up an endowment-style fund that supports state pension systems and housing efforts while spinning off interest earnings for programs including bridge maintenance, child care investments and property tax relief.

    SB 155 passed the Senate Taxation committee Wednesday on a 7-1 vote.



    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

    Related Posts

    One of UK’s ‘poshest suburbs’ where you can buy a property for £160k | UK | News

    Property

    The UK’s ‘best’ seaside town to move to in 2025 with properties on sale for just £70k | UK | News

    Property

    Can you still make money from UK property?

    Property

    Public Property Invest Asa acquiert deux propriétés adjacentes dédiées aux soins de santé et aux services communautaires en Finlande

    Property

    Lead Real Estate Co., Ltd annonce la vente d’une maison individuelle en projet, REAL PRO SERIES Ookayama à Tokyo

    Property

    Mortgage Advice Bureau reports 67% of borrowers who’ve purchased a property in the last twelve months were FTBs

    Property
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Picks
    Commodities

    Centaurus Energy Announces Plans to Focus on Investing Directly in Physical and Digital Commodities and Related Proposed Change of Business into an Investment Issuer

    Precious Metal

    Le Mali ferme les bureaux du géant minier canadien Barrick Gold à Bamako

    Commodities

    A PAIR OF JADEITE AND HARDSTONE PLANTS IN SILVERED-METAL JARDINIÈRES, LATE QING DYNASTY

    Editors Picks

    Le magazine « Le Marché » célèbre un an de succès sous le signe de la finance verte

    May 5, 2025

    Hong Kong police called to crypto store after woman scammed out of HK$93,000 of Tether

    October 26, 2024

    Powered Agriculture Equipment Market Size Worth US$ 209.1

    October 24, 2024

    ARS choisit SS&C pour soutenir sa gamme de produits à revenu garanti

    March 18, 2025
    What's Hot

    Indonesia posts first annual deflation in 25 years at 0.09% in February

    March 3, 2025

    Melania and Donald offer cryptocurrency meme coins

    January 20, 2025

    SRO: From CBDC, UPI ATM to Payments SRO: RBI lays out route map for fintech industry

    August 29, 2024
    Our Picks

    Budget 2025: A critical moment for agricultural transformation

    February 7, 2025

    Gold Nanorods Eliminate Infection Risk During Implant Surgeries

    October 29, 2024

    Trump’s ‘cyber summit’ gives digital currency new prominence and a large US role

    March 7, 2025
    Weekly Top

    India’s Digital Payment Surge: Currency and Convenience

    May 31, 2025

    Le numérique au service du développement : catalyseur, levier ou fracture ?

    May 31, 2025

    Appeal against important court ruling about cryptocurrency in South Africa – MyBroadband

    May 31, 2025
    Editor's Pick

    Energy Transfer and Sunoco announce strategic Permian Basin crude oil joint venture

    July 17, 2024

    Energy Bill Runs into Storm

    October 24, 2024

    Trôo continue de mettre en valeur les artistes de la région

    May 13, 2025
    © 2025 Invest Intellect
    • Contact us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.