Close Menu
Invest Intellect
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Invest Intellect
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • Home
    • Commodities
    • Cryptocurrency
    • Fintech
    • Investments
    • Precious Metal
    • Property
    • Stock Market
    Invest Intellect
    Home»Cryptocurrency»Appeal against important court ruling about cryptocurrency in South Africa – MyBroadband
    Cryptocurrency

    Appeal against important court ruling about cryptocurrency in South Africa – MyBroadband

    May 31, 20255 Mins Read


    The South African Reserve Bank (SARB) has applied for leave to appeal a recent court ruling which found that cryptocurrency is not money and doesn’t fall within existing exchange control regulations.

    Specifically, it said the Pretoria High Court erred in finding that cryptocurrency is not considered money for the purposes of South Africa’s Exchange Control Regulations (Excon).

    Earlier this month, Judge Mandlenkosi Motha ruled that South Africa’s antiquated Excon rules do not apply to cryptocurrencies and require urgent reform.

    “Cryptocurrency is not money. The construction that cryptocurrency is money, by looking at the definition of money, which includes foreign currency, is strained and impractical,” he ruled.

    Motha’s ruling also had some strong words for the Reserve Bank regarding its failure to regulate cryptocurrency properly.

    “Cryptocurrency has been in existence for over 15 years; one cannot say SARB has been caught napping,” he said.

    “In the same way, intellectual property rights had a niche carved for them in exchange control regulations, cryptocurrencies need some legislative attention.”

    Motha said a comprehensive regulatory framework to address cryptocurrency was long overdue, explaining that the exchange control regulations were conceived for an entirely different purpose.

    “The consequences of the massacre of black people in Sharpeville reverberated inside the corridors of the Apartheid economy and shook the very foundations of the regime,” he stated.

    “To stem the tide of the resultant capital flight and a run on the rand, the Apartheid regime passed the Exchange Control Regulations in 1961, which, save for a few changes, is still in place.”

    “The vexed question is whether these 60-plus old Excon Regulations are fit for purpose to deal with the machinations in the world of cryptocurrency.”

    Motha’s remarks were part of a judgment in a case brought by Standard Bank to overturn an asset forfeiture decision involving a company it wanted to liquidate.

    The company, which was a Standard Bank customer, owed the financial institution over R41 million and had allegedly been linked to fraud.

    Unbeknownst to Standard Bank, SARB’s financial surveillance division (FinSurv) had begun investigating cryptocurrency transactions of several entities, including the company in question.

    The investigation started years before the liquidation and found that the company had bought bitcoins and transferred them to foreign cryptocurrency exchanges.

    As a result, FinSurv seized all the assets Standard Bank was hoping to liquidate to cover some of the debt. FinSurv cited exchange control violations as justification for the seizure.

    Standard Bank brought the matter before the High Court to argue that there was no exchange control violation, in part because the regulations didn’t account for cryptocurrency.

    In his analysis of the facts before the court, Motha summarised why cryptocurrencies defied existing notions of foreign currency and, therefore, exchange controls.

    “Cryptocurrency is an asset that is bought and sold. There are practical challenges and implications if cryptocurrency is viewed as money,” said Motha.

    “These are, inter alia: can one deposit cryptocurrency? Does one have to declare cryptocurrency when entering or leaving the Republic?”

    Motha cited an academic article that SARB and FinSurv put before the court, which said cryptocurrencies are nothing more than code on a digital ledger.

    “Thus, they exist anywhere and everywhere and have a global nature,” the article stated.

    Setback for SARB and FinSurv

    If the Supreme Court of Appeal does not overturn Motha’s ruling, it would be a significant setback for FinSurv.

    In 2021, FinSurv came down hard on South African banks to restrict how people may purchase cryptocurrency from offshore exchanges.

    As a result of the crackdowns, banks banned customers from using their payment cards to buy cryptocurrency from overseas exchanges.

    FinSurv also told MyBroadband at the time that any transfer of cryptocurrency out of South Africa was a criminal offence under existing exchange control regulations.

    This includes transferring assets from your own self-hosted wallet to individuals overseas or to decentralised exchanges.

    Regulators further warned that “staking” crypto assets could have tax and exchange control implications, though they did not clarify these implications.

    MyBroadband asked FinSurv detailed questions about this in 2021. While it did provide feedback on the mechanics of what was permitted, it did not explain the legal basis for its stance.

    When El Salvador declared Bitcoin legal tender in 2021, MyBroadband asked SARB whether this means it would be considered foreign currency in South Africa.

    This was based on a statement from regulators that the Excon defines foreign currency as any currency that is legal tender elsewhere in the world but not in South Africa.

    “The SARB has not taken a final position on the extent to which crypto assets may or may not fall within the definition of foreign currency as contemplated in the Exchange Control Regulations, 1961,” it said at the time.

    Notably, El Salvador reversed its decision in 2025 following pressure from the International Monetary Fund. While Bitcoin may still be used for payments, it is no longer legal tender.

    Having it both ways

    Lesetja Kganyago, South African Reserve Bank governor

    SARB’s argument now that cryptocurrency should be treated like money for exchange control purposes is a typical example of South African regulators wanting their bread buttered on both sides.

    The Revenue Service wants to tax gains on cryptocurrency trades and investments at the maximum possible rate as if it were regular money.

    However, SARB governor Lesetja Kganyago and other Reserve Bank officials have refused to even acknowledge them as “currency”.

    As early as 2018, former SARB deputy governor Francois Groepe said that they didn’t regard cryptocurrencies as currencies or securities.

    In fact, they preferred that the term “cryptocurrency” not be applied to them and that people instead call them “cyber tokens”.

    Kganyago expressed an updated view in 2021, stating that cryptocurrencies are more accurately described as “crypto assets”.



    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

    Related Posts

    One in four savers would consider buying cryptocurrencies as part of their retirement planning

    Cryptocurrency

    Cryptocurrency Live News & Updates : Shiba Inu Price Faces Potential Volatility Ahead

    Cryptocurrency

    Cryptocurrency: unlocking the digital vaults

    Cryptocurrency

    What’s the best Crypto to buy in August? This new Cryptocurrency could deliver 5x ROI bypassing ETH 2x

    Cryptocurrency

    Which Cryptocurrency Is More Likely to Be a Millionaire Maker? Dogecoin vs. Solana

    Cryptocurrency

    Is a Cryptocurrency Market Crash on the Horizon?

    Cryptocurrency
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Picks
    Property

    This US property makes the list of the world’s most beautiful hotels

    Precious Metal

    ORG Partners LLC Takes $39,000 Position in iShares Silver Trust (NYSEARCA:SLV)

    Precious Metal

    Colorado debuts “Silver Rush” uniforms vs. Cincinnati

    Editors Picks

    Why BOK is reluctant to increase gold reserves

    February 12, 2025

    Government reports 3% growth in Thai agricultural economy in Q1 2025

    April 26, 2025

    Silver Viper annonce un nouveau placement privé simultané

    June 19, 2025

    Restaurants and delis could run out of cheese after UK bans European cheese imports | News UK

    July 15, 2025
    What's Hot

    Measure J threatens Sonoma County’s agricultural heritage and economy — Close to Home

    October 20, 2024

    Utility company nixes proposal to add transmission system through Meeks Mountain area

    October 26, 2024

    How AI and Cloud Technology are Revolutionizing the 2024 Olympics

    July 28, 2024
    Our Picks

    A Market Rebound – La Voce di New York

    October 24, 2024

    Fourth Dominion – Diana’s Day Review

    August 14, 2024

    Vinesh Phogat CAS Hearing LIVE Updates: Final verdict on Phogat’s Olympic silver to be OUT today at 9:30 pm

    August 10, 2024
    Weekly Top

    North Korea unveils ‘unique technology’ in new air defence missile test

    August 25, 2025

    Farmers warn of crisis as poll shows 80% fear for survival and none back Labour

    August 25, 2025

    Kiwi raises $24 Mn in series B funding led by Vertex Ventures

    August 25, 2025
    Editor's Pick

    Hacker stole cryptocurrency worth $250,000 using fake Trump inauguration emails

    July 5, 2025

    UK has the slowest home sale process

    August 20, 2024

    En Afrique du Sud, les mineurs d’or poursuivent leur expansion loin de chez eux

    March 5, 2025
    © 2025 Invest Intellect
    • Contact us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.