Close Menu
Invest Intellect
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Invest Intellect
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • Home
    • Commodities
    • Cryptocurrency
    • Fintech
    • Investments
    • Precious Metal
    • Property
    • Stock Market
    Invest Intellect
    Home»Commodities»Scarcity vs. innovation: Recalling the “scholarly wager of the decade”
    Commodities

    Scarcity vs. innovation: Recalling the “scholarly wager of the decade”

    February 17, 20254 Mins Read


    One of the most famous bets in the past half-century — at least among economists — wasn’t about the Super Bowl or a presidential election. No, it was about the price of metals. That is, whether five critical metals would be worth more or less in 1990 than they were in 1980.

    Really, though, this was about how we consume natural resources and whether we would just gobble up more and more as the human population grew or figure out a better way to manage what the planet provides.

    Researchers are now looking at this question all over again, and Marketplace’s senior economics contributor, Chris Farrell, went back to the future along with “Marketplace Morning Report” host David Brancaccio.

    The following is an edited transcript of their conversation.

    David Brancaccio: What’s the full story on this crazy bet?

    Chris Farrell: So it’s famed biologist and environmentalist Paul Ehrlich, and he predicted population growth would deplete the planet’s resources, and the increasing scarcity of resources would drive commodity prices higher. Now, this iconoclastic economist Julian Simon, he just didn’t buy this forecast. He believed human innovation and ingenuity would overcome commodity shortages; prices would fall over time rather than rise. So, Simon, being an economist, challenged Ehrlich to put some money on the line.

    Brancaccio: All right, real money. Challenge accepted. Exactly what were they betting on?

    Farrell: OK, so they wagered on the decadelong price of five metals: copper, chrome, nickel, tin and tungsten. Ehrlich would win the so-called scholarly wager of the decade if the inflation-adjusted prices of these metals were higher in September 1990 compared to September 1980. Simon, of course, would win if prices were lower.

    Brancaccio: And I vaguely remember this: Simon wins the bet, right?

    Farrell: He does. So at the end of the decade, the world’s population had risen by 800 million people, while nominal prices and inflation-adjusted prices of each of the five commodities were down. Ehrlich wrote Simon a check. The bet, by the way, David — I mean, obviously it’s long over — but its meaning, its significance and its symbolism are still being debated 35 years later.

    Brancaccio: Enter some new research on this. What did you see?

    Farrell: Hannah Ritchie is a senior researcher at Oxford University and deputy editor of “Our World in Data.” And she looked at the price trend of the five metals starting in 1900. Prices didn’t change much over the past century, even though the economy is dramatically different today. Studies going back as far as 1840 show that a broader basket of mineral prices has been essentially trendless, she says.

    Brancaccio: All right, but what’s the big conclusion here?

    Farrell: So, looking at price trends over the long haul, she finds herself closer to Simon’s perspective about the impact of human innovation. For instance, she notes that the world produces 40 times as much copper annually and 250 times as much nickel as it did in 1900, yet prices aren’t that different from 1900, she says. The lesson in the price message: When resources become scarce, the price signal unleashes human ingenuity, and new supplies bring prices back down.

    Brancaccio: If past performance gives us some indication of the future, I guess. Marketplace’s senior economics contributor Chris Farrell. Thank you.

    There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

    You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

    Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.  



    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

    Related Posts

    ‘Could fundamentally change how we power our world’

    Commodities

    Your energy drink habit may lead to debilitating nerve damage – and it takes far less than you’d think to reach a toxic overdose

    Commodities

    the nu-metal giants keep the hits rollin’ in

    Commodities

    7 biggest changes in Metal Gear Solid Delta Snake Eater from the original

    Commodities

    Hundreds of Armenian trucks with agricultural products were “deployed” from Russia — EADaily, August 24th, 2025 — Economics, Russia

    Commodities

    Can you play Metal Gear Solid Delta Snake Eater on Xbox Game Pass

    Commodities
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Picks
    Cryptocurrency

    BOK launches digital currency pilot for real-world use

    Fintech

    Largest Fintech Fund in Credit Union Industry History, Curql Fund II, Closes with $360 Million

    Commodities

    Mercosur Outlook launch: Charting a course for sustainable agricultural growth amid uncertainty

    Editors Picks

    Trump metal tariffs widening to include furniture, knives, ACs

    August 19, 2025

    Should You Forget Bitcoin and Buy Solana Instead?

    October 26, 2024

    Donald Trump Leads Kamala Harris Despite Trailing in Electors: Nate Silver

    October 20, 2024

    Commodities and shipping groups ask lawyers for sanctions advice on return to Russia

    April 29, 2025
    What's Hot

    WinnerMining: Are cryptocurrency fluctuations making people panic? No, it’s the business opportunities of cloud mining.

    July 1, 2025

    Africa’s Agricultural Giants: Top 5 Countries with the Most Farmland

    March 5, 2025

    Florida insurance execs’ pay of $50M raises worry about firms failing

    June 27, 2025
    Our Picks

    Nasdaq, S&P 500 futures step higher as Netflix jumps after earnings beat

    October 18, 2024

    Which Investments to Keep Out of Your Taxable Account

    July 29, 2025

    Qonto passe à l’offensive pour devenir une vraie banque

    July 3, 2025
    Weekly Top

    Which Cryptocurrency Is More Likely to Be a Millionaire Maker? Dogecoin vs. Solana

    August 24, 2025

    Gujarat emerges as India’s copper hub, amid soaring demand from sunrise sectors – Industry News

    August 24, 2025

    Four quick and easy DIY tricks to boost your property value by nearly £30k

    August 24, 2025
    Editor's Pick

    Two Arrested for Alleged Copper Wire Theft in Kern County

    August 19, 2024

    Dividend Stocks To Consider In April 2025

    April 21, 2025

    Pakistan Contemplates Creating ‘National Crypto Council’ To Embrace Digital Currencies

    February 27, 2025
    © 2025 Invest Intellect
    • Contact us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.