Close Menu
Invest Intellect
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Invest Intellect
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • Home
    • Commodities
    • Cryptocurrency
    • Fintech
    • Investments
    • Precious Metal
    • Property
    • Stock Market
    Invest Intellect
    Home»Commodities»Chicago Utility’s Plan for Aging Natural Gas Pipelines Runs Up Against Energy Transition
    Commodities

    Chicago Utility’s Plan for Aging Natural Gas Pipelines Runs Up Against Energy Transition

    October 30, 20246 Mins Read


    If you ask Chicago’s gas pipeline utility, Peoples Gas Light and Coke Company, or PGL, the best way to fix the problem of leaks from underground gas pipelines, their answer is the most ambitious option — running new, upgraded plastic pipelines throughout the city, leaving their old network of leak-prone iron pipes behind.

    Consumer watchdogs, however, are calling foul. A newly published report by the Illinois Citizens Utility Board (CUB), a nonprofit utility watchdog established by the state legislature, finds PGL’s cost projections underestimate how expensive and time-consuming those upgrades would be, while massively overestimating how costly other options might be.

    Stay up to date with DeSmog news and alerts

    Going forward with the full pipeline upgrade plan backed by PGL would cause “historically unprecedented rate hikes, even assuming a stable customer base,” the CUB report warns. Chicagoans could see their average annual charges spike from $1,206 today to $2,424 or more by 2040, it finds, and customers could keep paying off those upgrades until the year 2100.

    Plus, those new plastic pipes would represent a massive investment in an energy future that may never materialize, the report adds.

    Chicago’s network of underground natural gas pipelines dates back nearly 200 years — an era before the electric lightbulb when gas-burning streetlamps were lit manually across the city.

    The city’s pipeline system, which today serves nearly 900,000 customers, is one of the oldest in the country — and it leaks.

    Those leaks not only put people’s immediate health and safety at risk (even when they don’t ignite), they also release methane, one of the most powerful climate-altering gases, into the atmosphere, accelerating climate change.

    The report, “People’s Gas: Escalating Business Risk in a Changing Energy Landscape” suggests that the Chicago utility is underestimating the impacts of the ongoing energy transition. It misses the ways that buildings today increasingly draw their heat from geothermal or electrical power — just as gas-light streetlamps from the pre-Civil War era gave way to electric ones.

    Instead of helping the city achieve its climate goals by cutting leaks, upgrading PGL’s pipeline grid could have the opposite effect, the report warns. “PGL’s strategy of expanding and modernizing fossil fuel infrastructure increasingly conflicts with the aggressive climate goals of the city of Chicago and Illinois,” it concludes.

    David Schwartz, a spokesperson for PGL, said any suggestion that the company’s cost estimates are off was false. 

    “This so-called ‘study’ completely ignores testimony that independent engineers and safety experts gave in front of state regulators —  that there is an ‘urgent need’ to continue replacing corroding pipes across Chicago that date back as far as the 1800s,” he told DeSmog, citing the company’s projections that its plan would cost $5 billion less than “what CUB and its allies proposed.” 

    “At the same time CUB is claiming to care about affordability, they fully support measures that would force Chicagoans to go ‘all electric’ — a move that would DOUBLE or TRIPLE heating bills,” he wrote in an email to DeSmog.

    A report by the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) reveals that electrification can help PGL-serviced households save money, mainly because the utility has increased prices, and regional wholesale gas prices have significantly risen over the past few years. 

    A Tough Problem

    “This gas transition problem is, I think, one of the hardest problems of the United States energy transition,” report author Dorie Seavey told DeSmog. “It’s really difficult.”

    “There are great concerns about the climate and health and environmental impacts of leaked and combusted methane – and there’s a lot of concern about how much these investments are costing,” she said. “And then there’s the incongruity between state and local and national climate and energy goals on the one hand and continuing to sink billions and billions of dollars into the natural gas system.”

    The usual incentives to keep costs down don’t tend to apply to natural gas utilities. Monopoly utilities are often guaranteed a set rate of return when they invest in building new power plants or upgrading their systems — with the paradoxical end result that the more your local gas utility company spends, the more profits it can collect.

    That setup is a recipe for creating stranded assets during an energy transition, the watchdog report warns, labeling managing those risks “a critical task for regulators nationwide.”

    Ultimately, what utility watchdogs fear is something of a bait-and-switch: Instead of simply finding and fixing pipeline leaks or retiring leaky pipelines as customers transition over to other fuels, utility companies are pushing to upgrade entire gas distribution networks, replacing old pipes with ones made from higher-tech materials.

    PGL has argued that pipeline upgrades enable the energy transition because they’ll eventually allow the company to switch over to renewable natural gas (RNG) or hydrogen.

    But “the company has yet to supply any credible evidence demonstrating that these fuels are feasible and cost-effective,” CUB wrote in response.

    In contrast, heat pumps and geothermal energy are often cheaper and simpler options — and that could pull customers away from pipelines altogether.

    A half-dozen states — not including Illinois — already routinely require gas utilities to consider other non-pipeline options “as a substitute for pipeline replacement,” the report notes.

    Already, Illinois regulators have hit the brakes on PGL’s proposed system upgrades, demanding a closer examination. An administrative judge’s recommendation is expected on November 25. The Illinois Commerce Commission is due to complete its probe of PGL’s System Modernization Program in January.

    The results of that probe could be a bellwether for utilities across the U.S., especially with state and local elections underway. While utility regulators in Illinois are appointees, utility commissioners are elected in 10 other states nationwide — and eight have “active races” for commissioners this November, according to the Energy News Network, potentially raising the scrutiny faced by natural gas utilities nationwide.

    Already this summer, Moody’s dropped the credit outlook for PGL’s parent company, WEC Energy, from “stable” to “negative,” the report noted, adding that Moody’s cited “a deterioration in the Illinois regulatory environment, uncertainty about future capital expenditures,” and “the probability of an adverse outcome of the pending [System Modernization Program] investigation.”

    “The situation that Peoples Gas faces is emblematic of pressures across the nation that mature, incumbent gas-only utilities may encounter,” the CUB report warns, “as they grapple with rising infrastructure costs, regulatory changes, and competitive threats from disruptive technologies.”



    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

    Related Posts

    2025 Chemistry Nobel Goes to Molecular Sponges That Purify Water, Store Energy and Clean Up the Environment

    Commodities

    Mumbai Agricultural Produce Market Committee donates Rs 45 lakh to CM relief fund for Maharashtra’s flash flood affected areas | Mumbai News

    Commodities

    OSU agricultural economy professor cites ‘black swan’ events behind industry’s bailout need

    Commodities

    Cenovus Energy raises takeover offer for MEG Energy

    Commodities

    Groundbreaking metal-organic framework research wins Chemistry Nobel Prize 2025

    Commodities

    Cenovus sweetens takeover offer for MEG Energy

    Commodities
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Picks
    Investments

    Transcript : Tube Investments of India Limited, Q4 2025 Earnings Call, May 16, 2025

    Stock Market

    Top Dividend Stocks (April 2025)

    Stock Market

    How amp’s smart gym technology changes home workout routines

    Editors Picks

    Ukraine to export no more than 20% of its agricultural output to Europe after it joins EU

    March 4, 2025

    House Of Investments Inc affiche un résultat net attribuable de 1,38 milliard de pesos pour l’exercice

    May 2, 2025

    Raveum Has Officially Paved the Way for Indian Investors to Enter the U.S. Property Market

    October 17, 2024

    Canadian among Metal Supermarkets’ 2024 scholarship winners

    August 14, 2024
    What's Hot

    Column: Coal used to be Australia’s commodity export king, but gold is coming

    July 1, 2025

    Iowa DNR investigating copper spill near Garner; dead fish reported

    August 30, 2025

    S&P 500 tops 6,600, Nasdaq extends record streak as Fed decision nears

    September 15, 2025
    Our Picks

    VCSEL Performance Improves with Mode Filtering Using Metal Apertures | Research & Technology | Oct 2024

    October 15, 2024

    Defiance Silver Corp. annonce un placement LIFE par l’entremise d’un courtier pouvant atteindre 8 M$ CA

    June 4, 2025

    Energy Trader Vitol Fined by US for Bets on Live Cattle Futures – BNN Bloomberg

    August 14, 2024
    Weekly Top

    European Fintech Groups, Crowdfunding Advocates Send Letter To Policymakers Regarding Financial Data Access Regulation (FIDA)

    October 8, 2025

    AI Fintech Optasia To Raise R6.3 Billion In South African Share Sale To Fund Global Acquisitions

    October 8, 2025

    Cristiano Ronaldo pushes back once again against retirement

    October 8, 2025
    Editor's Pick

    Silver, the poor man’s gold, beats precious metal to set a record in festive season

    October 31, 2024

    Five Strategies to Strengthen Your Position as a Reputable Broker

    August 4, 2025

    No-brainer Silver ETF to buy for 2025

    March 10, 2025
    © 2025 Invest Intellect
    • Contact us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.